They keep raising the bar on us!
Via
.
We are all photographers. It used to be, if you wanted to be a photographer, you had to have a camera and some film. But as a mark of total cultural upheaval, Kodak doesn't manufacture Kodachrome anymore. You can still pick up rolls of Tri-X, the quintessential black-and-white film that all hobbyists used to start out with (and photojournalists would swear by, although I gather that now professionals have gone on to T-MAX). Instead of film today we use digital media, and we've traded in our cameras for telephones. But there is a boon in digital photography with all those non-cameras available in half the devices we all own. We now take more pictures than we ever have before. And there are so many digital photography apps that it's impossible to keep track.
Are they art? Well, they certainly incorporate a lot of things we think of as art in other contexts. They have a strong visual component, and they often incorporate music, but then again, my supermarket uses visual tricks and music to get me to buy more cauliflower, so those alone may not be enough. They also have narrative, that is, a beginning, a middle and an end, and in that are like movies (which also have the visual and audio components). That the narrative is driven by the viewer/user and not the creator (in a way, although the creator is still ultimately responsible for the parameters of the experience), gives some critics pause. The question has to boil down to our definition of art. If art is something that moves us on a combined emotional and intellectual level, which is not a bad definition, than I’d have to say that they are art. Marcel Duchamp’s found art, which is a signed piece of old plumbing, moves us on a combined emotional and intellectual level. Monet’s lily pads move us on a combined emotional and intellectual level. Citizen Kane and Hamlet move us on a combined emotional and intellectual level. Beethoven does it. Why not BioShock? Let’s put it this way. Even if you believe that video games aren’t there yet, they’ll be there soon enough. And just as all paintings and movies and plays and music don’t move us on a combined emotional and intellectual level, neither will all video games. That any of them do, makes those that do, art. The ones that don’t? Either they’re just commerce, or bad/failed art.